It's about the comparability of products from Skinceuticals. It’s the gentler of the two. Propylene glycol is often confused with other, toxic glycols. I know there are some confusions and doubts about the serums from Cosmetic Skin Solutions versus SkinCeuticals. How Skinceuticals CE Ferulic (which we reviewed last year) justifies the $100 difference is unclear.
I applied both products on my face and compare the results. Thanks for watching! Timeless 20% C + E + Ferulic Acid Serum. (How to make Google Chrome show RSS page? I can't speak for the quality of the product itself, but the customer experience speaks volumes about how they run their company (and probably how they make their product too). My understanding is that propylene glycol is potentially toxic if consumed in large quantities (which is the case with most ingredients) but as it is typically used in cosmetics and food, is in-fact, safe. Thanks to Marsha, I have discovered a new set of product twins – identical ingredients in differently branded and, often, very differently priced products. On the CSS website, the ingredients list has changed and is different that was is published at the bottom of the article... an effect since their lawsuit with L'Oreal? However, just to refresh, MAP is more stable - and much cheaper - but not nearly as effective as L-ascorbic acid. I don't want to use their Phloretin CF because of the high % of denatured alcohol which would surely dry out my skin. Not Good. Johnathan, their chemist, wrote back that it is actually a vitamin C derivative called magnesium ascorbyl phosphate (MAP). If your skin can tolerate high concentrations of Vitamin C without problems, opt for Timeless 20% Vitamin C + E Ferulic Acid Serum instead. I read reviews and one lady said that she checked the ph level at home( using PH testing strips) and it was 0! Skinceuticals has a patent on the formula in the pH range of 2.5 - 3 only, which is the optimal pH range for L-Ascorbic Acid (LAA). And lastly, are their products packaged in a bottle with a box or just a bottle? question: CSS directions states to apply the serum in the morning- can you use it as a nighttime serum as well?
The only thing that isn’t the same is the price. The Ferulic is there to stabilise the L-Ascorbic acid in the formulation. Marsha, please see my response to Suz. Additionally, if anyone has kept the product for a while, it eventually oxidizes. I too believe Skinceuticals gives a better result. Ferulic acid, by the way, is a great ingredient. I LOVE this CSS serum! Thank you Marta and Marsha! Not feeling confident about putting their stuff on my face now. I was concerned that these two products were really the same so I wrote down the … Regardless what anyone things, its a scientific fact and can not be argued. Suddenly they aren’t available. I was a few clicks from ordering the SkinCeutical product last night. If you have a real address that can be verified, please post it.
I have also noticed that CSS has taken the Vitamin C + E Serum out of their webpage. He added that the confusion may have come about because “one reader may have asked about MAP, and our explanation was the difference between it and L-Ascorbic acid as Vitamin C crystals.”. The cheaper brand cannot go as low as skinceuticals and therefore, product does not have the same delivery. I will update if I can get more information about this cheaper version of SkinCeuticals. I know this is an old column but I have to convey how thankful I am....a few months back I was feeling rather low do I decided to go surf the net and shop. This. The only missing link is the percentage of Ferulic Acid. Cheaper Alternatives of the Star Products II - SkinCeuticals C E Ferulic, 7 Less Known but Top Notch Beauty Products. Cosmetic Skin Solutions C E Ferulic is colorless and odorless while SkinCeutical C E Ferulic is not. I'm sure that that's not a safe level and can harm your skin. I used both and didn't notice any difference in quality but I chose CSS because they don't test on animals. The Skinceuticals CE Ferulic serum has been shown to work in clinical studies, which means they've got the formulation correct. The Cosmetic Skin Solutions version of Vitamin C+E with Ferulic acid is shipped world wide including South Africa. So, a … There is a tremendous amount of false information spread about propylene glycol. As you can see at the end of this post, the ingredient lists of C E Ferulic Serums from these two brands look the same, both claiming that they have 15% of stabilized Vitamin C, 1% Vitamin E, and 0.5% ferulic acid. If and when I compare the pH of this and SkinCeuticals … I was thinking I might return the C and try this one. EXPAND THIS BOX FOR MORE INFO!! I waited 5 weeks and finally gave up. fast forward 3 days and in a short time i noticed my skin 'brighten and liven ' up....i love this..thank you v much to TIA and all its supporters in the feedback
It is well worth much more but I sure do appreciate this money saving wonder for my face :). I would love to see a comparison article for SC Phloretin & CSS Phloretin serums. Customer service replied as follows: Mary. Anyone who tries contacting CSS will encounter the same lack of transparency. I reponded with "So, is it NOT the MAP form of Vitamin C, correct?" Their diverse antioxidant formulation is very comparable, effective, much less expensive, which makes it a more favorable selection among many! I buy my L-ascorbic acid at lotioncrafters.com. And that is the only difference I can tell. Who doesn't want to save money?? “As indicated on the website descriptions per each antioxidant serums and onthe label under "Ingredients", L-Ascorbic acid is used as our form of Vitamin C.” The lists of the ingredients can all compare themselves and form their opinions on this. Thanks. My … Skinceuticals … As to the type of Vitamin C, it states L-ascorbic acid on the product. Jacqui, do come back and tell us how you like CSS. I will update if I can get more information about this cheaper version of SkinCeuticals. I have found the very best way to apply L-ascorbic acid, is to make a fresh batch in the palm of my hand daily, mixing a pea size amount with whatever serum I choose. A post shared by SkinCeuticals (@skinceuticals) on Sep 30, 2018 at 9:01am PDT “One of the trade-offs of filing a patent is that the method for creating the product must be revealed. The ingredients are identical to the more expensive Skinceuticals C+E serum … I got no response as of August 18th.. Is basically a diference of PH, but in the end, its almost the same efects. I work as a Product Manager in the Cosmetic Industry and I guess it is because Skinceuticals might have sued CSS as they hold the patent for this product, and the formula is almost identical. Personally I would stick to the one that has shown efficacy. New to SkinCeuticals so far - great results. The flagship serum Skinceuticals CE Ferulic ($142) was a bestseller until a copy cat came along called Cosmetic Skin Solutions at a mere cost of $39.95 (read more on these product twins). Not ingredients but the way they are formulated so that they penetrate the skin and deliver the active molecules.
What are the percentages of vitamins C, E and ferulic acid? A lil over 2 weeks I purchased a few CSS products and have been using the 20% AOX product everyday since, sometimes twice/day. Thanks for the info about how wonderful CSS ce ferulic is compared to SC's version of it. Hi all! The actual manufacturing cost is below $10. Skinceuticals has a patent on the ph. Has anyone ever used Obaji before? Also has anyone who has ordered from Australia had any problems with Aus customs confiscating their CSS products/ parcel? Besides degarding from sunlight and oxygen exposure, it is even more unstable and prone to degrading when mixed in a serum. I believe Cosmetic Skin Solutions CE Ferulic is between 3 - 3.5. The only negative is the price. COSMETIC SKIN SOLUTIONS IS NOW SOLD THROUGH AMAZON AND SO IS SKINCEUTICALS! Skinseuticals comes clean and states 0.5%; ISS is silent. I make handmade serums and want you all to know a better way of handling the highly unstable L-ascorbic acid. -Darrell. Both are very effective, the Skinceuticals is only SLIGHTLY more effective. The Ferulic Acid is not there as an active ingredient, that part is just MARKETING. Skinceuticals costs $142 and Cosmetic Skin Solutions costs $39.95. I have combination skin which is sensitive and I also have mild rosacea. Jacie raved about it and that it is comparable to the very popular Skinceuticals’ C E Ferulic serum but at a much lower … [source: http://www.cosmeticskinsolutions.com/Product-List/]
Discover the go-to vitamin C serums that top dermatologists and beauty editors swear by. Links to purchase the products featured in this post: Timeless … I'd finally decided to try Skinceuticals CE Ferulic although formerly I refused due to the cost. Can either CSS & SCCE products be used during pregnancy? Cosmetic Skin Solutions C E Ferulic: rated 4 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. Although I once again revamped my skincare routine, the brightness is dramatic, my pores utterly disappeared and it really brightened my under eye area! Would the CE Ferulic acid or Hydra B5 be too rich for my skin type? That being said, the pH of CSS is still within the effective range, it's just not the optimal range for LAA. So I wonder why their chemist would say that the vitamin C is magnesium ascorbyl phosphate, unless they have changed their formula?? Anyone can throw chemicals together but not everyone can get the conditions and delivery mechanism perfect. I first heard of Cosmetic Skin Solutions’ Vitamin C+E serum on Twitter. MAP and SAP are superior forms of vitamin c because they will be stable for a longer period. It is about 3. Hi Pat,
I called several times and sent an email about this matter, but no one will answer my questions. It has better packaging, too. No idea. I'm wondering the same thing. My skin has remained even toned, sun spot free, and still looks radiant. (Thank you, Marta and Marsha!) Ingredients in Cosmetic Skin Solutions C + E Ferulic Serum:Water, Ethoxydiglycol, L-Asorbic Acid, Propylene Glycol, Glycerin, Laureth-23, Alpha Tocopherol, Phenoxyethanol, Triethanolamine, Ferulic Acid, Panthenol, Sodium Hyaluronate. Thanks! Hi Sonali, I am sorry but I don't know what the pH level of this formula is. Love it! Cosmetic Skin Solutions C E Ferulic Ingredients: So is the CSS have the same ingredients they maybe not effective as Skinceuticals. Contrary to the ingredient lists in this post, they do NOT both contain L-ascorbic acid. I looked at CSS vitamin c product line and read they produce only fresh vitamin C's....which makes me to believe the SC samples I tried was expired. CSS uses L-ascorbic acid. Well, as much as I hate to be the bearer of bad news, I must inform everyone: these two products are not product twins! The lack of transparency really makes me question the legitimacy of the company. I am impressed on the improvement and complexion of my skin. I compared all of the ingredients and found them to be the same but I am no chemist so I can't speak for those comparisons. I liked the texture of how it glides on smoothly and absorbs quickly. Cosmetic Skin Solutions This is a good alternative to SkinCeuticals and comes at a much lower price. Thank you, TIA (Marta)
I have a not-uncommon skin condition called Malassezia folliculitis, and, improbably, propylene glycol is by far the best treatment I've found for it. Here is the current full ingredient list for CSS CE Serum:
Practically dupes at very … I'm a scientist and I think I understand what the reason might be. I have a bottle of Cosmetic Skin Solutions C+E Ferulic Serum. It is more beneficial for the skin to receive less of an active ingredient over a longer period of time than more of an ingredient over a less amount of time. And also remarkable is that the
I used both and I could not tell the difference in terms of effects on my skin. Their customer support is useless. Please view here:http://www.cosmeticskinsolutions.com/Product-List/Vitamin-C-E-Serum-Advanced-Formula.html. Check out our website for more details. Massage for Puffy Eyes – Inward or Outward? First, SkinCeuticals uses vitamin C as L-ascorbic acid, the only form of vitamin C that prevents transepidermal water loss, meaning it keeps moisture in your skin. In the book 'Cosmeceuticals and Active Cosmetics, Third Edition', the authors write about the very careful balancing act required when putting together an antioxidant formulation and show the beneficial results of the Skinceutical's product. It's fishy and unfortunately the reason I won't buy from them again. They are the exact same formulas. I tried Skin Solutions C+E serum. Is. It looks luminous! Outrageous. The samples were a brownish color, is it suppose to be like this, and isn't brown a sign of oxidized vitamin C? Darrell, thank you for posting such a well-reasoned and informative comment. I just purchased the Obagi 10% vitamin C serum and at first I was very pleased until 2 days later when my face started peeling and burning. I don't know everything about it, but they have scientists in suits I've seen them. Statements about the toxicity of ß-propylene glycol and ethylene glycol are often taken out of context and inaccurately used to describe propylene glycol, which becomes some of the greatest source of mis-information. Can you verify if the PH level of this serum is safe to use on skin. http://www.wellsphere.com/skin-health-article/are-other-vitamin-ce-ferulic-serums-as-effective-as-skinceuticals-cosmetics-solutions-timeless-skinmedica-compared/1609583, Hey ladies!! Cosmetic Skin Solutions C E Ferulic is colorless and odorless while SkinCeutical C E Ferulic is not. It brightens my face and I have no issues with scent or how it feels. Again, I made multiple phone calls, sent emails and left messages with people who could supposedly answer my questions. I was curious about the "stabiized vitamin C" referred to in the ingredient list posted on the CSS website so I wrote to the company. why don't you show the %'so for all the ingredients. Our team is committed to excellence in the scientific field of developing clinically-validated cosmeceutical antioxidant skin care products! Why does Skinceuticals CE Ferulic cost $100 more than CSS? The results on amazon and other review sites prove without a doubt it's a solid product. ... try Cosmetic Skin Solutions. Whether this is meaningful or not, I have no idea! The only thing that isn’t the same is the price. I was searching sites for the best price when I first came across this website, specifically this column. The ingredients are the same, but the % of the ingredients isn't listed in CSS.
In my mid 40s and combating early signs of aging I needed to up my skin care game. Another effective, affordable serum is Drunk Elephant’s Day Serum. Water, Ethoxydiglycol (solvent), L-Ascorbic Acid (vitamin C), Propylene Glycol (humidifying and delivery ingredient), Glycerin (humidifying and skin-identical ingredient), Laureth 23 (emulsifier), Alpha Tocopherol (vitamin E), Phenoxyethanol (solvent and preservative), Triethanolamine (pH balancer), Ferulic Acid (antioxidant that also enhances the stability of vitamins), Panthenol (moisturizer – alcohol form of vitamin B), Sodium Hyaluronate (moisturizing skin-identical ingredient).
With a pH of 3.3 – 3.5, there is big difference in performance relative to SkinCeuticals and Cosmetic Skin Solutions. JUNE 2010. Detailed information about the toxicity and safety of propylene glycol can be found here:
Skinceuticals holds the patent on stabilized ascorbic acid compositions, the ideal formulation with maximum bioavailability with the least likelihood of irritation at a low pH. Referring to the Post from Elyse regarding the form of C that is in the newer "Twin". All these results in about 2 weeks for this little price! I have both sera from Skinceuticals and by Cosmetic Skin Solutions tried and couldn't find a difference in my skin in the effect. The is no way to justify the price for the Skinceuticals product. I didn’t know each product could be identical. I just finished my 2nd bottle and will buy another. Hi Marta,
It's ultra finely ground, very fresh, and 100% pure. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propylene_glycol
2020 cosmetic skin solutions vs skinceuticals